Paper retraction consequences Sep 21, 2016 · Information of retraction. com Reasons for this type of paper retraction include fraudulent data, plagiarism, untrue authorship claims, multiple submissions of the article, or general misconduct related to professional codes of ethics. An investigation by the publisher found a number of articles, including this one, with a number of concerns, including but not limited to compromised peer review process, inappropriate or irrelevant references, containing nonstandard phrases or not being in scope of the journal. The retracted paper was a study of the effects of oxidative stress on acquired epilepsy in rat models published in Brain in 2017 (Pauletti et al. 6 papers are retracted; that is about 0. It comprises 51,275 publications, encompassing various details such as title, author names, country affiliations, journal and publisher names, publication subjects, types of retraction, reasons of retraction, publication and retraction Twelve years after publishing a landmark study that turned tens of thousands of parents around the world against the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine because of an implied link between vaccinations and autism, The Lancet has retracted the paper. Retraction Watch started a database which now feeds many different publication systems and makes this possible. Managing Bid Retraction Consequences Like a Pro. 00 to 53. The author presents evidence that toxic coal combustion fly ash is the most likely aerosolized particulate sprayed by tanker-jets for geoengineering, weather-modification and climate-modification purposes and describes some Nov 21, 2024 · Consequences: The paper was retracted within days after widespread criticism from the scientific community. Nov 23, 2024 · Consequences: The paper was retracted within days after widespread criticism from the scientific community. Sep 1, 2020 · Retraction of publications is an increasing problem in science and one of the most troublesome issues for biomedical journals. We find Dec 7, 2022 · We investigate the citation frequency of retracted scientific papers in science. Peer review is an important though insufficient means of safeguarding academic integrity, and thus all researchers, including trainees, are responsible for helping Oct 25, 2018 · It includes more than 18,000 retracted papers and conference abstracts dating back to the 1970s (and even one paper from 1756 involving Benjamin Franklin). sábado, 29 outubro 2022 / Published in definition of housing in malaysia. Tessier-Lavigne has retracted 3 papers in light of the ongoing controversy surrounding his research, and had to issue corrections to When Nature retracted the original study in June, it cited Salzberg’s critique and noted that all of the paper’s authors agreed to its retraction. ∙ In order to marry Josephine, Rizal wrote with the help of a priest a form of retraction to be approved by the Bishop of Cebu. Articles retracted for simple plagiarism or duplicate publication were not included. EndNote too, I think. Prior publications three or four degrees of separation from the retracted paper experience citation declines of 14. Science just wants to know if the paper should be retracted or not. Not all publishers, for instance, publicize or clearly label papers they have retracted, or explain why they did so. Here’s an article explaining in detail about retractions in academic publishing and how it impacts researchers. After publication of the Report “Site-selective enzymatic C‒H amidation for synthesis of diverse lactams” (), efforts to reproduce the work showed that the enzymes do not catalyze the reactions with the activities and selectivities claimed. Even though it is very difficult to define the sinking part of the iceberg, looking at the good, the bad the the ugly of the floating part also inform us proper insights so we can imagine the giant shadow of the picture. Almost 80% of papers he correspond has been Sep 6, 2017 · The paper, "The career effects of scandal: Evidence from scientific retractions," has just been published online by the journal Research Policy, and will appear in a print edition as well. Oct 1, 2024 · Example of a retraction notice. Teamwork pervades modern production, yet teamwork can make individual roles difficult to ascertain. paper retraction consequences One of the retracted papers was retracted and replaced (Retraction Watch, 2022). Following the retraction guidelines. Hydroxychloroquine or chloroquine Aug 28, 2014 · Retraction is a way of alerting the research community of a paper’s questionable credibility. The first author of the paper, Abdiel J. Dec 1, 2018 · Semantic Scholar extracted view of "Retraction notice to "Effects of dynamic diffraction conditions on magnetic parameter determination in a double perovskite Sr2FeMoO6 using electron energy-loss magnetic chiral dichroism" [Ultramicroscopy 176, 2017, pp. May 3, 2016 · The paper was retracted, and the journal published a clear notice that it was due to serious fraud, as several paragraphs and the results were stolen (verbatim) from a previously published paper. Nov 16, 2021 · According to a study conducted by MIT and published in 2017, authors can experience a 10–20% decrease in citations after a formal retraction. As the number of retractions continues to climb, it is essential to tackle the underlying factors driving these trends, such as the intense pressure on researchers to publish and the potential exploitation by paper mills. 9% of the articles were retracted due to data falsification or fabrication. Retractions and Paper Mills Decline Effects Meta-Research Methodological Critiques Paper retracted as co-author admits forgery. 5% of retractions were due to self-plagiarism and 36% due to fraud. Jul 16, 2019 · Reporting a paper to the journal. Oct 30, 2024 · An analysis of 180 retracted English-language papers published from 2000 to 2010, along with their 851 secondary studies citing them, showed that the retracted papers were cited over 5000 times. Jul 1, 2019 · Abstract. Jun 23, 2015 · The word "retraction" sends a shiver down many a scientist's spine. Feb 20, 2020 · Retraction is crucial part of academic publishing. 3% (p < . Retracted publications generally remain visible and searchable, but the intention of retraction is to mark them as “removed” from the citable record of scholarship. Stephanie Seneff (born April 20, 1948) [1]: 249 is an American computer scientist and anti-vaccine activist. To examine the effect of retraction, we Many times the html version of the published paper will have a note in the bibliography that the paper has been retracted. Overall, the number of research paper retractions from India has gone up substantially: from 595 between 2017 and 2019, to 1,350 Aug 26, 2024 · The retracted paper, published in a prestigious journal, had seemingly provided strong evidence supporting this hypothesis. More image manipulation, more retractions, this one in Science. Retracting a paper has historically been associated with academic fraud. ” The paper, “ Mitosis Inhibits DNA Double-Strand Break Repair to Guard Against Telomere Fusions ,” is from the lab of Daniel Durocher , a professor of molecular genetics at the University of Toronto. However, it seems that I am still the only one at my department who knows about this misconduct, probably because people do not follow that journal. 19 Since each control faculty member entered the dataset because it is the author of a paper that appeared in the same journal and issue as a retracted paper, we can assign to them a counterfactual date of retraction, which is the year in which Dec 4, 2013 · The retraction comes one year after the paper was published, and seems to be a response to the avalanche of criticism the study has faced. According to the retraction, “no causal link was established between MMR vaccine and autism as the data were insufficient”. Descriptive statistics, Pearson's correlation coefficient, and simple linear regression were used to analyze the data. ” This trial was a special case, however, since “the authors seem to have actually used intramuscular progesterone, under the impression that Aug 28, 2024 · For example, in June, a Nature paper 1 on stem cells was retracted amid concerns about the reliability of the data shown — 22 years after its publication, having amassed nearly 5,000 citations two or more authors and often include senior and young researchers, the consequences of retractions can differ between them. Along with, overarching theme of “retraction” and “predatory journals” have emphasized the importance of studying related infrastructures. We have also made changes to the search functionality to maintain reliability. The retraction has not been signed by Shane R. Flores, contacted the Sep 21, 2024 · Article retractions happen across all types of research and can happen to any researcher at any institution. 4 We 3 Merton coined the Matthew Effect after the biblical passage “For unto ev ery one that hath shall Abstract Teamwork pervades modern production, yet teamwork can make individual roles difficult to ascertain. Dec 2, 2011 · According to the retraction notice published yesterday (December 1) in the journal, which published an editorial expression of concern on the paper last month, this paper is among the many that “included fabrication of data,” and placed the blame solely on Stapel: “Coauthor Lindenberg was in no way involved Nov 12, 2020 · Background Retracted articles continue to be cited after retraction, and this could have consequences for the scientific community and general population alike. Yadav in the journal Acta Metallurgica Sinica (English Letter) reads: “The editor has retracted this article because Figure 7a-7d, as well as parts of the text were duplicated from the following article. The Strike System: It’s Not The Retraction Watch Database PLEASE NOTE: The best way to make use of this database is to download it from here, thanks to the acquisition of the database by Crossref. The Retraction Watch Transparency Index; The Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker. The primary source of data is the Retraction Watch database obtained via Crossref (Hendricks et al. 1 Making a correction to a published paper. Philippines' National Hero, Dr. The They might then forego the chance of a high-impact paper, with consequences for their own performance metrics. The notice went live just a few hours after Arnold’s tweet:. For a retraction, this indicates that something in the paper was wrong enough that invalidated (or called into question) some major part of the published work. 1 2 Fraudulent papers have negative consequences for the scientific community and the general public, engendering distrust in science, false claims of drug or device efficacy, and unjustified academic promotion, among Nov 30, 2020 · This extensive review report has been officially submitted to Eurosurveillance editorial board on 27th November 2020 via their submission-portal, enclosed to this review report is a retraction Jan 2, 2020 · The paper has been cited once, according to Clarivate Analytics’ Web of Science. ’ A statement is issued clearly stating all the related information about the paper and a valid reason for the retraction. Methods; The Retraction Watch Leaderboard. Dec 17, 2024 · The letter called for the paper to be retracted. It’s amazing it got published…and the amount of money they were able to scam using this is depressing. , 2017). Retraction led to a decrease in average annual citation frequency from about 5 before, to 2 citations after retraction. While retractions do not eliminate papers from the record, they have far-reaching consequences for retracted authors and their careers, serving as a visible and permanent signal of potential transgressions. Our context is article retractions in the sciences. Casad (Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2019[May], Vol 45[5], 700-714). For the period of five years before and after retraction, we counted the citations to papers in a sample of over 3,000 retracted, and a matched sample of another 3,000 non-retracted papers. When a paper dies from mistakes, a scientist’s reputation has no bearing on readers’ reactions. 30% of the retracted papers are retracted within 1 year of publication. A cross-sectional study was conducted, using Retraction Watch database, Journal Citation Reports and PubMed as data sources. Therefore it is not possible to partition the analysis by type of misconduct. Aug 18, 2020 · “Retracted” may be watermarked across the pages or in the header section of pdf documents under the control of a journal or publisher, and retraction letters may be linked to the papers in search engine output, but a bad paper is like embarrassing photos from our youth: there is no way to reliably recall hard or digital copies once they Jun 5, 2024 · Senior author plans to retract her team’s highly cited study on the cause of Alzheimer’s disease after acknowledging that the paper contains manipulated images. Table 1 shows the main characteristics of retracted paper mill papers. The journal faced backlash for its lack of editorial oversight, especially regarding the review and approval of figures in the pre-publication process. Apr 26, 2017 · The retracted study from Wakefield et al. I am worried about my reputation if I have a retracted paper. Nov 8, 2024 · I guess the argument could be that 1) unauthorized versions of the software theoretically may not generate accurate results, but also 2) as was said in the notice, “One of the conditions of submission of a paper for publication is that the article does not violate any Intellectual Property rights of any person or entity and that the use of any software is made under a license or permission The week at Retraction Watch featured: Introducing the Retraction Watch Sleuth in Residence Program; Our list of retracted or withdrawn COVID-19 papers is up past 450. Percentage of paper mill retractions with respect to total retractions. [ 5 ] Mar 11, 2024 · However, a paper being retracted due to fraudulent practices or academic misconduct is a graver situation. See full list on link. Consequences: Retraction of papers; Loss of funding; Damage to career and reputation; Legal consequences in some cases; Trivia and Facts. The paper, by Reina Lewis of the London College of Fashion, still appears online, but an entry on the Russian database eLIBRARY indicates it was retracted for being “in violation of standards. ”28. Time-Sensitive Requirements That Matter; Category-Specific Restrictions to Keep in Mind; 2. The aim of this paper is to examine to what extent retraction policies of academic journals and publishers address Feb 2, 2021 · Easy mistake with serious consequences. The statement also states who retracted the article. of the Committee on Publication Ethics, we have decided to retract the original published version of the Article and publish a corrected version using the retraction and republication Readers will see some familiar entries, such as the infamous Lancet paper by Andrew Wakefield that originally suggested a link between autism and childhood vaccines. Top 10 most highly cited retracted papers; The Retraction Watch Mass Resignations List; What people are saying about Retraction Watch Dec 31, 2023 · Another Tessier-Lavigne paper published in Nature was issued an expression of concern over “manipulation of research data” this month, implying it will likely face correction or retraction Feb 7, 2010 · Scientist: Autism Paper Had Catastrophic Effects The prestigious British medical journal Lancet took a rare step this week: It retracted a 1998 paper that sparked a firestorm about potential links Aug 21, 2023 · In this Viewpoint we discuss Chemistry manuscripts retracted during the 2001–2021 period (a total of 1292 journal articles retrieved from the Retraction Watch database). However, in practice, some retracted articles continue to be treated by Oct 17, 2024 · To reduce the harmful long-term consequences of high blood glucose in people with type 1 diabetes, Reference: Nature Medicine paper Retraction shows ‘good science is hard’ Feb 28, 1998 · 6 March 2004 Ten authors on the 1998 paper issue a retraction (Lancet 363, 750, 2004), and The Lancet's editor says the journal, in hindsight, should not have published the study (Lancet 363, 747 The authors of a paper on the antidepressant effects of ketamine have retracted their article for a lack of reproducibility -- but readers have no way of knowing that because the journal declined to Oct 30, 2019 · There is evidence that authors of publications that cite retracted work remain unaware of the retraction, 5 and this has potentially important consequences for their work, that of subsequent researchers, and for clinical practitioners and patients. Consequences of Withdrawing a Research Paper from Journal Nov 28, 2022 · Introduction. Pandey was working at CSIR-NIIST, while 13 retracted papers were published when Dr. As criticisms of the paper mounted, Micronoma negative consequences. 01). Chavez, Niall Bolger and Bettina J. (2004). Nov 28, 2022 · The publication of the first paper mill paper was in 2004 and the first retraction was in 2016; by 2021, paper mill retractions accounted for 772 (21. In short, the problem is systemic: science is often in too much of a hurry, for reasons that are understandable but not beneficial to science itself. Previous studies have highlighted Sep 21, 2023 · Evidence and consequences of academic drift in the field of dental research: A bibliometric analysis 2000–2015 Overall, each retracted paper had a median IF of 3, out of which 69% had an IF 1182 retracted paper mill papers were identified. Let’s assume that after these words of warning, you are still interested in reporting a paper to a journal. Please advise me. Of the 330 analyzed Apr 24, 2024 · Although a paper can be retracted for many reasons, when the cause is potential misconduct, institutions must conduct thorough investigations. This article is being retracted at the request of all of the authors. The retraction notice states Elsevier and the International Society of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, which co-own the journal, decided to retract the paper because of ethical issues, “as well as concerns raised by three of the authors themselves regarding the article’s methodology and Jul 18, 2024 · Twenty-three papers that have been retracted were published when Dr. Some papers are retracted Dec 17, 2024 · Legitimate Circumstances for Bid Retraction; 1. Therefore, if Sep 6, 2019 · Daniele Fanelli: There's evidence to suggest that a cost in citations can result from a retracted paper, but only when the retraction is due to scientific misconduct. Nov 17, 2020 · Before any more damage has occurred, you self-retract your paper. paper with the corrected data by all the previous clinical reviewers and the statistical reviewer. The only way a paper referencing a retracted one might need to be retracted is if the study heavily relied on the retracted study and if the authors didn't do a good job at describing the relationship between the retracted study and their own. Feb 27, 2014 · An international team of researchers from the NIH, Harvard, the University of Michigan, and two Chinese universities — Fourth Military Medical University and China Medical University — has retracted their 2012 paper in Nature after they — and a number of other groups — were unable to reproduce the key results. Jun 21, 2024 · In December, the journal published an expression of concern for the paper, stating it was investigating concerns “regarding the origins and integrity of the transport data” in several of the paper’s figures “with the cooperation of the authors. Atlas, M. [2] [3] She is a senior research scientist at the Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL) of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). Mar 3, 2020 · Features & opinion What we learnt from retracting a paper “Someone I admire retracted a very important paper when I was a young scientist,” says Nobel-prizewinning chemist Frances Arnold, who The next episode in the saga was a short retraction of the interpretation of the original data by 10 of the 12 co-authors of the paper. We then investigate citation behavior to the prior publications of each author involved in the retracted work. Through 34. We present data on the retractions in the journal Science, between 1983 and 2017. The retraction of papers in fields such as medicine can prevent patients from being subjected to potentially harmful treatments. Only articles retracted due to documented or suspected serious misconduct were included in this study; 95. The publication of the first paper mill paper was in 2004 and the first retraction was in 2016; by 2021, paper mill retractions accounted for 772 (21. This retraction tells the scientific community that the research we published is invalid. We present WithdrarXiv, the first large-scale dataset of withdrawn papers from arXiv, containing over 14,000 papers and their associated retraction comments spanning the repository's entire history through September 2024. 0000000000023583 The case of Mark Tessier-Lavigne •Dr. Nov 12, 2024 · Data collection and filtration. STAT - "The issues with this paper, along with concerns with more than 50 other articles co-authored by four of Dana-Farber’s top May 23, 2021 · This study aims to profile the scientific retractions published in journals indexed in the Web of Science database from 2010 to 2019, from researchers at the top 20 World Class Universities according to the Times Higher Education global ranking of 2020. You’ll note that some papers — including the #8 most cited paper — received more citations after they were retracted, which research has shown is an ongoing problem . Rizal, put so much effort into writing his books about the wrongdoings of the Spaniards. Sep 8, 2020 · The stigma is rooted in the fear of every researcher that a retracted article, which would remain accessible online with an additional tagline of retraction notice, is like a scar seared into the Dec 10, 2024 · To elucidate the potential damage that neglecting research integrity governance may inflict on university innovation, this study utilized retraction and innovation data from Chinese Double First-Class Initiative universities between 2007 and 2017 to systematically explore the impact, mechanism, and economic consequences of academic misconduct Oct 16, 2013 · The number of published papers being retracted is increasing dramatically and is higher than ever before. In academic publishing, a retraction is a mechanism by which a published paper in an academic journal is flagged for being seriously flawed to the extent that their results and conclusions can no longer be relied upon. The scientific community begins doubting the integrity of the concerned research group. Jan 1, 2023 · The risk of having one’s paper retracted, and the attendant consequences thereof, can serve as a deterrent against unethical practices. 8%) of the 3544 total retractions. Biomedical original papers, reviews, case reports and letters with at least one author affiliated Consequences of Retraction in Scientific Teams * Ginger Zhe Jin, University of Maryland and NBER retracted paper was authored in a team 4and where the authors have a single retraction event. These broad Dec 4, 2024 · Retractions play a vital role in maintaining scientific integrity, yet systematic studies of retractions in computer science and other STEM fields remain scarce. Most often it’s due to ignorance, says Josh Nicholson, co-founder of Abstract Background. The paper was retracted based on the "evidence of systematic manipulation of the publication and peer-review process" found by the publishers. Managing the Aftermath; 3. These retracted studies put over 428,000 enrolled participants and 79,690 at-risk patients [7]. Many journals publish retractions that present ambiguity about the reasons for their action, leaving outside observers unclear about the precise nature of the problem. Nov 6, 2024 · Publishers have a vital role in educating researchers about research integrity, ethical conduct, and the retraction process along with its consequences. The conventional and professional- albeit slow and ineffective – way of reporting papers with concerns is to write to the Editor in Chief (EiC) of the journal in which the paper was published. Through text mining and analysis of 12,940 retraction notices from web of science and original websites, we found that most of the retraction notices contain basic elements such as who requested the retraction and reasons for retraction, but there is less mention of process information such as retraction policy, who Jun 16, 2015 · In the latest paper, Pierre Azoulay at MIT and his co-authors found that scientists who are more “eminent” face a stronger citation penalty after retraction – but only in the case of misconduct or fraud. S. To determine whether journals differ in frequency of retracted articles and whether there is a relationship between retraction frequency and journal impact factor, we carried out a PubMed search for retracted articles among 17 journals ranging in impact factor between 2. 3 days ago · A 2014 paper in Science by a lab in Toronto has been retracted after a December expression of concern raised “potential data integrity issues. The Seralini paper was published in November 2012 in Food and Chemical trial begins when the paper is released to the wild; exposed tocountlessintelligent,insightful,andmotivatedmindscri-tically evaluating the work. shows that the effects of paper retraction may go beyond academia and extend to other aspects of society. Pandey has been associated with CSIR-IITR Oct 27, 2020 · Position Paper on the Rizal Retraction The consequences brought by the tyranny of the Spanish regime in the past days resulted for the people to pave their own way to achieve freedom, hence going against the Spanish government to attain what we crave as a countrymen of our the Philippines. That instructor did this with 100's of students throughout the years. Nature, 421(6925), 775. 34% of the papers published in the journal. Oct 16, 2013 · I am sad because I recently got an email from the editor of a journal in which my paper is published, requesting me to retract the paper because they found some errors in my data and statistical analysis. Flores, Tanya A. Retracted articles can have negative consequences, particularly when they are used in meta-analyses or clinical guidelines. Errors and concerns unrelated to misconduct constituted 26% of Sep 5, 2017 · As the scholars acknowledge, the new paper leaves open a number of related questions about retraction policy and the effects of retractions. 4 . Twohigh-profilepapersrelatedtoCOVID-19werepub-lished in May and retracted in June 2020: RETRACTED: Mehra MR, Desai SS, Ruschitzka F, Patel AN. A researcher whose paper has been retracted due to misconduct is treated more sternly in the field. Indeed, it has been noted that the consequences of retractions are comparatively minor for eminent authors who benefit from the reverse Mathew effect2 since “they are less likely to have a paper retracted, the duration from Mar 2, 2023 · If the paper has already been published online or in print, it may not be possible to withdraw it entirely. " by Z. Both the university and paper retraction consequences. Dr. 1097/MD. Generally, a retracted paper would not be cited after it's retracted, so using it to support an argument is obviously problematic. C. Sep 19, 2022 · Background Retraction is a mechanism for alerting readers to unreliable material and other problems in the published scientific and scholarly record. After the decision to retract the paper has been made, the online version is marked and (or) the pdf version is watermarked ‘retracted. , 2023) in February 2024. The Matthew effect suggests that communities reward eminent team members for great outcomes at the expense of less eminent team members. 5% of Chemistry manuscripts were retracted due to misconduct; of them, 40. It is not a perfect window into the world of retractions. I may not get a grant for my next study. Article retractions irreversibly damage the authors’ reputation. Documentation and Communication Best Practices. The scientific community Nov 6, 2013 · Figure 3 presents our main analysis, examining retraction effects on scientists' prior work. An examination of the retraction reasons reveals that one-fourth of retractions were due to numerous causes, mostly in Q2 journals, and another quarter were due to data problems, with the majority happening in Q1 publications. Sep 21, 2022 · Retractions in academic publishing are a clear signal to the researcher that the validity of their paper has been brought into question. To isolate the effect of single retractions, we exclude cases where authors have multiple retractions Oct 14, 2022 · By 4y after the first retraction the proportion of authors actively publishing at least one paper/year was <50%, annual publication rates were <50% of the pre-retraction rate, and only 22% of Indeed, it has been noted that the consequences of retractions are comparatively minor for eminent authors who benefit from the reverse Mathew effect2 since “they are less likely to have a paper retracted, the duration from publication to retraction is longer, and citation loss is less severe. Scientific misconduct, which includes plagiarism, fabrication, and falsification of data or images, is the most common cause of retraction of biomedical papers. springer. As noted by Retraction Watch, Elsevier's Ain Shams Engineering Journal withdrew two papers exploring dam failures after complaints from Flow Science, the Santa Fe, New Mexico-based maker of a computational fluid dynamics application called FLOW-3D. Jose P. However, what is the consequence of self-retraction in your career? Consequences of Retracting a Paper. To examine the ef- Here’s the notice for “Deservingness to state health services for South – South migrants: A preliminary study of Costa Rican providers’ views,” a paper in Social Science & Medicine by Kate Goldade and a colleague: Continue reading Social sciences paper retracted for lack of ethical approval Nov 2, 2018 · retracted paper was authored in a team and where the authors have a single retraction event. ” The notice continued: Continue reading Russian philosophy journal cites law banning “LGBT propaganda” in retraction Nov 6, 2023 · There is no clarity on the action taken against the teachers. If you notice a mistake, especially one that results in a difference to how the results are presented, then you should approach the editor about publishing a correction (also termed a corrigendum or erratum - plural errata). In this case, more often than not, the scientific community is not as forgiving. 4 We then investigate citations to the prior publications of each author involved in the retracted work. Jun 27, 2019 · Similarly, a retraction note published for a 2014 paper by Prof. where the retracted paper was authored in a team and where the authors have a single retraction event (that is, we do not look at extreme cases where an author is revealed to be a systematic fraud). There are many reasons why citations fail to acknowledge a paper’s retraction. This series touches upon various aspects of retraction, such as, the implications of retraction, why the journal retraction rate is rising, and reasons behind the continued citation of retracted papers. Elsevier retracted 31% of papers, with the majority published as Q1, followed by Springer (11. The paper — by Gilles Seralini and colleagues — was published in Food and Chemical Toxicology last year. This retraction is to the anti-GMO world what the retraction of the infamous Wakefield Lancet paper was to the anti-vaccine world. No researcher would want that. Overall, retracted paper mill papers were mostly published in journals of the second highest Journal Citation Reports quartile for impact factor (n=529 (44. 1, 2, 3 The impact of retraction is negative whether it is due to misconduct or not, and it is believed that fraud is more frequent than assumed. In the new era of publication, scientific misconduct has become a focus of concern including extreme variability of plagiarism, falsification, fabrication, authorship issues, peer review manipulation, etc. Although retracted papers still represent a miniscule proportion of the total published literature, the rate of increase in retractions is alarming, as retracted papers tarnish Less attention has been paid to whether papers that report unethical research-for example, research performed without appropriate concern for the moral rights and interests of the research participants-should be retracted. DOI: 10. Jan 4, 2025 · The week at Retraction Watch featured: Introducing the Retraction Watch Sleuth in Residence Program; Our list of retracted or withdrawn COVID-19 papers is up past 450. 1007/s10765-021-02918-6 Corpus ID: 239413118; Retraction Note to: Consequences of Binary Chemically Reactive Flow Configuration of Williamson Fluid with Entropy Optimization and Activation Energy Pi’s copy of Rizal’s retraction has the same text as that of Fr. Plus, why cicadas shriek so Sep 29, 2018 · Retractions are rare in science, but there is growing concern about the impact retracted papers have. The Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker now contains more than May 20, 2013 · The Retraction Watch FAQ, including comments policy. GED103: THE RETRACTION OF RIZAL. Researchers, journals, and associated institutions suffer reputational harm. 5%), predominantly as Q2. Mar 25, 2024 · The Publisher has retracted this article in agreement with the Editor-in-Chief. 484. Oct 14, 2010 · Although this matter is under further review, these authors wish to retract the paper in its entirety, and regret any adverse consequences that may have resulted from the paper’s publication. There are more than 50,000 retractions in The Retraction Watch Database — which is now part of Crossref. I don't have even have any idea how one can manipulate the process and what so ever. Absolutely fascinating…the combination of errors that had to occur. We showed that 58. Analyses of the impact of a body of clinical trial reports subject to research misconduct have Nov 1, 2017 · Our sample includes 23,620 publications by 376 retracted authors and 46,538 by 759 control authors. Just over half of these papers had four to six authors; almost all authors of paper mill retractions came from Chinese institutions, followed by far fewer authors from Indian institutions; and more than three quarters of papers had a first author who This study investigates the ontological features of retraction notices. In such cases, the journal may be able to issue a correction or retraction of the paper, but the original version will still be available for readers to access. We . For more information, read our User Guide. Ideally, for retractions to benefit the scholarly record as much as possible: Sep 7, 2024 · The week at Retraction Watch featured: Journal to retract two articles more than six months after VA said they had fake images; Exclusive: Editor resigns after he says publisher blocked criticism of decision to retract paper on gender dysphoria Reports the retraction of "Cardiovascular and self-regulatory consequences of SES-based social identity threat" by Abdiel J. Understanding eBay’s Bid Retraction Process. We find Nov 28, 2013 · A heavily criticized study of the effects of genetically modified maize and the Roundup herbicide on rats is being retracted — one way or another. 4, 5 Retracted publications usually cause lack of trust in medical Aug 11, 2015 · The widespread, intentional and increasingly frequent chemical emplacement in the troposphere has gone unidentified and unremarked in the scientific literature for years. However, it might be just the floating part of the iceberg. In addition, we find in this study that citing retracted papers does not seem to lead to any serious academic consequences. But what are the real career repercussions for researchers whose papers are retracted? For biomedical scientists, the average impact is about a 10% penalty on future citations to prior papers, according to a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper posted in May. The Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker now contains more than Aug 18, 2022 · The journals have a different goal. Overall, retracted paper mill papers were mostly published in journals of the second Examining citation losses by degrees of separation from the retracted paper , negative citation spillovers are found for papers up to four degrees of separation in the citation network (looking backwards in time). What is the consequence if the authors do not agree with retraction? Sep 17, 2024 · The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine in June retracted the 2012 paper, “Matched sample comparison of intramuscular versus vaginal micronized progesterone for prevention of preterm birth. . The paper had 19 authors from eight institutions and multiple funders, including NIH, the European Union’s Notices of retraction should: • be linked to the retracted article wherever possible (ie, in all electronic versions) • clearly identify the retracted article (eg, by including the title and authors in the retraction heading) • be clearly identified as a retraction (ie, distinct from other types of correction or comment) We had a journal club about this paper as well as the rebuttal paper by the Salzberg Lab. Although we’re curious about the details—and sometimes our news division, which is editorially independent of the research department, might decide to look deeper—the matter of whether the problem was a rogue postdoc or graduate student, sloppy science, or outright fraud by the Aug 12, 2021 · One of my paper is under retraction process due to some errors in my figures. This study was conducted to analyse the association of retraction on citations received by retracted papers due to misconduct using two-time frames: during a postretraction period equivalent to the time the article had been in print Nov 14, 2024 · Updated An academic journal has retracted two papers because it determined their authors used unlicensed software. A retracted paper reflects negatively on the authors’ credibility and the journal’s editorial process. Wang et al. Effects and safety of tanreqing injection on viral pneumonia: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis: Retraction, Medicine: November 25, 2020 - Volume 99 - Issue 48 - p e23583 doi: 10. The decision is to retract. We study this phenomenon in reverse, investigating credit sharing after damaging events. The notice states: A study in Scientific Reports in 2013 found that the authors of retracted articles do suffer a “retraction penalty”—a decline in future citations of their unretracted papers: “Citation penalties spread across publication histories, measured both by the temporal distance and the degrees of separation from the retracted paper. 212-217]. It is very unlikely that you will be in a position where you will need to think about retracting your paper. This case is not yet closed. The Office of Research Integrity (ORI) in the U. In May 4, 2024 · The aim was to describe biomedical retractions and analyse those retracted in 2000–2021 due to research misconduct among authors affiliated with European institutions. Citations function more as a roadmap than anything else; they indicate where information is coming from. In our empirical analysis, we collect retracted articles in the Web of Science where the retracted paper was authored in a team and where the authors have a single retraction event. ” On June 13, the journal retracted the paper. Retraction Apr 19, 2024 · In hindsight, perhaps the most sobering aspect of the retraction discussed here is that the true reason the paper attracted the ire of the open access publisher, as was highlighted in its letter that triggered the retraction (Retraction Watch 2021), was not necessarily anything written in the paper itself, but a news feed about it that Jan 5, 2020 · Yet, Arnold’s retraction and admission garnered such attention because it is a rare thing to do these days. 8% Jun 11, 2023 · Retracting academic papers is a fundamental tool of quality control when the validity of papers or the integrity of authors is questioned post-publication. Mayack, who maintains that the results are still valid. consequences. In our empirical analysis, we collect retracted articles in the Web of Science where the retracted paper was authored in a team and the authors have a single retraction event. A retraction notice titled “Retraction: [article title]” signed by the editor and, if appropriate, by the authors is published in a subsequent issue of the journal, is paginated and is listed in the table of contents. defines fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism as research misconduct. Balaguer’s “exact” copy but follows the paragraphing of the texts of Rizal’s retraction in the Manila newspapers. Retracted articles are not removed from the published literature but marked as retracted. People used the word “courage” to describe what she did, which means that there is Sep 2, 2024 · The consequences of retraction extend beyond mere academic discourse, leading to reputation damage, financial losses, and much more. Sarah Johnson, a neuroscientist not involved in the original study, explains: “The amyloid beta hypothesis has been both a beacon and a point of contention in Alzheimer’s research. Each year, approximately 2. Even Zotero will alert you if you have a retracted paper in your library. cqcgqfhd pobfop waf osri xfzynwbc dfxm gtzm ekjn xgxjs hebguyun